How to spot an AI applicant
Artificial intelligence (AI) is not only transforming the way we work, but also the way we apply for work. More and more job seekers are using AI tools to write their resumes, cover letters, and responses to selection criteria. These tools promise to help applicants stand out from the crowd, tailor their applications to specific roles, and avoid common mistakes.
But how can HR professionals tell if an applicant is using AI to write their application? And what are the implications of this trend for the hiring process?
Signs of an AI applicant
There is no definitive way to detect an AI applicant, but there are some clues that can raise suspicion. For example, an AI applicant may:
- Use flawless grammar, spelling, and punctuation, without any typos or errors.
- Use sophisticated and varied vocabulary, without any repetition or redundancy.
- Use precise and relevant keywords, without any filler words or vague phrases.
- Use consistent and appropriate tone, style, and format, without any mismatch or inconsistency.
- Use specific and detailed examples, without any generalization or exaggeration.
Of course, these signs do not necessarily mean that an applicant is using AI, as some human applicants may also have excellent writing skills. However, they can indicate a level of perfection and polish that is uncommon and unrealistic for most human applicants.
Is it ethical to use AI to write applications?
There is no clear-cut answer to this question. Some might argue that using AI to write applications is a form of cheating, as it does not reflect the true skills and abilities of the applicant. Others might contend that using AI to write applications is a smart and efficient way to leverage technology, as long as the applicant can back up their claims in an interview or assessment.
As HR professionals, we need to be aware of the potential risks, issues, and challenges that AI applications pose. For example, how can we ensure that AI applications are fair and unbiased, and do not discriminate against certain groups of candidates? How can we verify the authenticity and originality of AI applications, and avoid plagiarism and fraud? How can we differentiate between candidates who use AI to write applications, and those who do not?
The importance of strong assessment tools
One way to address these challenges is to use strong assessment tools in the recruitment process. Assessment tools are designed to measure the knowledge, skills, abilities, and other attributes that are relevant for the job. They can include tests, interviews, simulations, work samples, and references.
Assessment tools can help us to evaluate the suitability and fit of candidates, regardless of whether they use AI to write their applications or not. They can also help us to reduce the reliance on resumes and cover letters, which are often subjective and unreliable sources of information. By using assessment tools, we can ensure that we hire the best candidates based on their actual performance and potential, rather than their AI-generated documents.
The use of AI for both writing and assessing applications
Another way to deal with the rise of AI applications is to use AI for both writing and assessing applications. AI can help us to automate and streamline the recruitment process, saving time and resources. AI can also help us to analyze and interpret large amounts of data, enhancing our decision-making and reducing human errors and biases.
However, using AI for both writing and assessing applications also comes with its own challenges. For example, how can we ensure that the AI tools we use are valid, reliable, and fair, and do not introduce new forms of bias or discrimination? How can we maintain the human touch and the personal connection with candidates, and avoid alienating or frustrating them? How can we balance the use of AI with the use of human judgment and intuition, and avoid over-reliance or under-reliance on AI?
Conclusion
AI is changing the game of job applications, and we need to be prepared for it. There is no right or wrong to people using AI to write their applications, but we need to consider the pros and cons of this practice. We also need to use strong assessment tools in the recruitment process, and be careful about how we use AI for both writing and assessing applications. By doing so, we can ensure that we hire the best talent for our organization, and create a fair and transparent recruitment process.
The Policy for the responsible use of AI in government has been developed to help guide and address safe and responsible use of AI in government roles. The policy aims to embrace the benefits, strengthen public trust and adapt over time. This took effect on 01 September 2024.
Did you realise this article was produced by AI?